The Unexpected Nostalgia of Waiting for a New Witcher
There’s something magical happening in The Witcher community. Despite The Witcher 4 being years away, fans are already experiencing waves of nostalgia – not just for the previous games, but for the anticipation itself. A recent Reddit thread titled “I’m feeling nostalgic here” captures this unique phenomenon perfectly.

The Comfort of Returning to a Beloved World
What’s remarkable isn’t just that players are reminiscing about Geralt’s adventures, but how they’re romanticizing the very act of waiting. Many describe:
- Rewatching the original Witcher 3 teaser trailers and remembering their first reactions
- Replaying the trilogy while imagining how new tech will enhance the next chapter
- That special tingle of excitement when spotting small references to the School of the Lynx
It’s as if the community is savoring this pre-release period, knowing they’ll someday look back fondly on these days of speculation and hope.
I’m feeling nostalgic here
byu/Fa1se-Personality inWitcher4
Why This Game Feels Different
The Witcher 4 carries a unique emotional weight because:
- It marks the first mainline game without Geralt as protagonist
- It’s coming after CD Projekt Red’s redemption arc following Cyberpunk
- The fantasy RPG landscape has changed dramatically since 2015
Yet fans aren’t anxious – they’re warmly remembering how Witcher 3 defied expectations, and trusting this team to deliver magic again.
Also, Read
- The Witcher 3 Memes That Prove the Game Is Still Hilarious Years Later
- The Witcher 4’s Stunning Tech Demo Shows the Future of Console Gaming
- Geralt and Yennefer’s Surprising Age Gap in The Witcher – Bigger Than You Think!
The Beautiful Paradox of Next-Gen Nostalgia
There’s something poetic about feeling nostalgia for memories not yet made. As one fan beautifully put it: “I know I’ll someday miss theorizing about this game with all of you.” The community isn’t just waiting for a game – they’re consciously creating moments they’ll later reminisce about.
Perhaps this is The Witcher’s true power: not just telling great stories, but becoming part of ours.