Red Dead Redemption 2’s Arthur Morgan is one of gaming’s most beloved characters, and fans can’t stop imagining who could bring him to life in a live-action adaptation. While Rockstar Games has never hinted at a movie or TV show, the fanbase is obsessed with casting the perfect Arthur. From Jensen Ackles to Henry Cavill, the debate is heating up—and not everyone is happy with the suggestions. Let’s dive into the drama and see who’s in the running (and who’s getting a hard “nope” from fans).
Who Should Play Arthur Morgan? The Fan Favorites
Fans have thrown around a lot of names for who could step into Arthur Morgan’s boots. Henry Cavill, known for his roles in The Witcher and Superman, has been a popular pick—but not everyone’s convinced. “No offense to Cavill, but he’s just not Arthur,” one fan commented. Another contender is Brandon Sklenar, who stars in the Western series 1923. While some fans think he’s a great fit, others argue it’s just because he’s already in a cowboy hat.
Then there’s Jensen Ackles, famous for Supernatural and The Boys. Ackles has a strong fanbase, but when his name came up on Reddit, the response was mixed. “I love Jensen, but as Arthur? Nopedy nope,” one user wrote.
Why Fans Are So Picky About Arthur Morgan
Arthur Morgan isn’t just any character—he’s a rugged, morally complex outlaw with a heart of gold. Fans argue that casting someone “too pretty” or “too Hollywood” would ruin his everyman appeal. “Arthur’s supposed to look like he’s been through the wringer,” one Reddit user pointed out. “He’s a rough, mid-30s guy in the late 1800s. That’s like being 50 today!”
This level of detail shows just how much fans care about staying true to the character. For them, Arthur isn’t just a role—he’s an icon.
Should Red Dead Redemption Even Get a Live-Action Adaptation?
While the casting debate rages on, some fans are asking a bigger question: Should Red Dead Redemption even be adapted into a movie or TV show? “It’s already the best interactive movie there could possibly be,” one fan argued. Others worry that a live-action version could never capture the game’s emotional depth and stunning visuals.
Still, the idea of seeing Arthur Morgan on the big screen is hard to resist. If done right, it could be a masterpiece. But as fans have made clear, it all comes down to the casting.
Also, Read
- Assassins Creed Shadows Free Download: Claim Limited-Time Twitch Drops Now
- Red Dead Redemption 3’s Most Optimistic Release Date Is Still Years Away
- Red Dead Redemption 2 Players Shocked to Learn They’ve Been Hunting Wrong for Years
Who Would You Cast as Arthur Morgan?
The debate over who should play Arthur Morgan in a live-action Red Dead Redemption adaptation is far from over. From Jensen Ackles to Henry Cavill, fans have strong opinions—and even stronger rejections. But one thing’s for sure: Arthur Morgan is a character worth getting right.
What do you think? Who’s your dream pick for Arthur? Share your thoughts in the comments below and let’s keep the conversation going!