Major Hogwarts Legacy 2 Request
The magical world of Hogwarts Legacy captured the hearts of millions, becoming one of the most-played single-player games on PlayStation 5. But as excitement naturally shifts to the potential for a sequel, players are uniting around one major feature they believe would define the next game: a meaningful morality system.

While the first game allowed players to explore the vast grounds of Hogwarts and beyond, many felt their choices lacked lasting consequences. A recent discussion on Reddit, where fans shared their most-wished-for sequel features, revealed a powerful consensus. The top request, by a significant margin, was for a karma system that reflects a player’s actions throughout their journey.
The community isn’t asking for a simple “good vs. evil” slider. Instead, fans are hoping for a nuanced system where decisions exist in shades of grey. “I’d like a morality system but I don’t want it to be black and white. I want to use the unforgivable curses and still do good,” one fan elaborated, highlighting a desire for complex character alignment.
This sentiment was echoed by others who want their choices to have tangible, often unexpected, outcomes. Some suggested a “hidden” morality system that isn’t explicitly shown to the player, revealing its impact only through subtle story shifts and character reactions as the narrative unfolds.
The call for a deeper roleplaying experience doesn’t stop at morality. Other highly requested features include a relationship system, allowing for deeper bonds with companions and iconic characters. Many fans also expressed a desire to see their witch or wizard grow beyond their school years, potentially pursuing careers as an Auror or even returning to Hogwarts as a professor.
Also, Read
- Hogwarts Legacy Mod Finally Adds Full House Point System Fans Wanted
- How a Netflix Deal Could Disrupt the Hogwarts Legacy 2 and HBO Series Link
- Netflix’s Potential Warner Bros Bid Could Reshape Hogwarts Legacy 2
These requests point to a shared vision for Hogwarts Legacy 2: a living, breathing Wizarding World that reacts authentically to the player’s presence. After a successful first outing that established a solid foundation, the community is eager for a sequel that offers true agency, making every spell cast and every choice made feel truly meaningful.
With expectations sky-high, the developers at Avalanche Software have a clear mandate from their dedicated fanbase to weave a more immersive and consequential magical tale next time around.